Best Soft Structured Baby Carriers – From Newborn to Toddler

The below list includes the Best Soft Structured Baby Carriers on the market. Including newborn carriers, multi-position carriers, and toddler carriers. New and improved versions of old favorites, and brand new designs are popping up daily, so I’m constantly adding to this list.

Below I’ve provided short descriptions for each soft structured baby carrier, as well as links to my full in-depth reviews. These reviews include a full list of features, both positive and negative feedback, price comparisons, and video demonstrations. If you find one that you like, read the full review and get the whole picture.

Best Soft Structured Baby Carriers

Boba 2G Classic

Boba Classic 2G - Earth - Front Carry

Boba Classic 2G @ Amazon for $89.99


Customer Rating: 124/137 = 90%

  • Price: $100.00
  • Positions: (2)Front facing in, or back
  • Min & Max: 15 – 45 pounds
  • Description: The Boba 2G is one of the best rated soft structured baby carrier out there. People who own them, worship them. It’s rare to find a baby carrier that so many people feel so strongly about, that’s why it’s at the top of my list.  What makes the Boba 2G Classic so special? First of all, it’s one of the only soft structured baby carriers on the market that offers detachable foot stirrups. The only other one is its sister carrier, the Boba 3G, listed below. The seat is taller and wider than most, which makes it perfect for toddlers.  It also offers a removable sleeping hood, and the shoulder straps and waist belt offer plenty of padding. Unfortunately the Boba 2G won’t be available for much longer. The new Boba 3G Carrier, listed below, is it’s replacement, and although it truly is an awesome baby carrier, sometimes the oldies are the goodies. So, if you’re interested, check out the Boba Carrier 2G Review for more information.

 

Boba 3G Carrier

Boba 3G Baby Carrier- Montenegro - Front facing in

Boba 3G @ Amazon for $108.70


Customer Rating: 58/70 = 83%

  • Price: $125.00
  • Positions: (2)Front facing in, or back
  • Min & Max: 7 – 45 pounds
  • Description: The Boba 3G is quite similar to the Boba 2G Classic. The main difference is in the carrying weight capacity. The Boba 3G allows you to carry a newborn from 7 pounds up to 45 pounds, without the need for an additional infant insert. It actually converts to a newborn carrier with just a few simple adjustments. Like the 2G, it also offers detachable foot stirrups. The only difference is that the Boba 3G’s foot stirrups offer a few more adjustments. Also, this soft structured baby carrier offers side adjustment straps that allow for easier breastfeeding. They actually pull your baby closer, making it easier for them to latch on, and stay on. Now, the Boba 3G does have one pocket on the waist belt, but it’s for holding the sleeping hood when it’s detached. You could try and use it for necessities, but it’s not very big. It does offer a nifty purse strap holder on the shoulder strap though, which keeps your purse from sliding off your shoulder while you’re out and about. Check out the Boba 3G Review for more information. Or, if you’d like to learn more about the differences between the 2G and the 3G, read the Boba Carrier Comparison.

 

ERGObaby Carrier

ERGO Baby Carrier - Camel - Front Facing In

ERGO Baby Bundle (w/Insert) @ Amazon for $135.00


Customer Rating: 347/420 = 83%

  • Price: $115.00
  • Positions: (3)Front facing in, hip, or back
  • Min & Max: 15 – 45 pounds (will support a newborn with an infant insert sold separately for $25)
  • Description: The ERGO Baby Carrier is by far, the MOST popular soft structured baby carrier on the market. Over the years ERGO has added a number of new carriers to their line-up, yet the original still holds the number one position. I feel pretty confident when I say that the ERGO Original is probably the most comfortable soft structured baby carrier out there.  So what makes it so special? For starters, the one-inch high density foam shoulder straps and the quarter inch high density foam waist belt offer superior comfort.  Not to mention the soft ergonomic seat for your child. Another reason why I like the ERGO Baby Carrier so much, is the fact that it offers a huge zippered pocket for necessities. I don’t need much when I’m out and about, just my debit card, keys, and cell phone, all of which fit nicely into this zippered pocket. The only thing that stinks is the fact that you have to purchase an infant insert separately to use it with your newborn. For more information, including where to buy, read the ERGO Baby Original Review.

 

Beco Gemini Baby Carrier

Beco Gemini Baby Carrier - Front Facing-Out

Beco Gemini @ Amazon for $129.00


Customer Rating: 139/164 = 85%

  • Price: $129.00
  • Positions: (4)Front facing in, front facing out, hip, or back
  • Min & Max: 7.7 – 35.3 pounds
  • Description: The Beco Gemini is definitely one of my favorites. It’s stylish, versatile, and comfortable.  It’s one of the only soft structured baby carriers, aside from the Babybjorns, that offers the forward facing-out carrying position. I find that a lot of parents transitioning from a Babybjorn prefer to have the option of front facing out, therefore they choose the Gemini. Now, this soft structured baby carrier can be used from 7.7 pounds up to 35 pounds. You don’t need to purchase an infant insert separately, it has an easy to use width alternating base for smaller babies. It also has head support that folds down, and you can easily breastfeed while carrying. The shoulder straps are well padded, and it offers a wide padded waist belt for lumbar support. For more information, including where to buy, check out the Beco Gemini Review.

 

Pikkolo Soft Structured Baby Carrier

Pikkolo Soft Structured Baby Carrier -Brown - Front Facing-out Carry

Pikkolo @ Amazon for $129.00


Customer Rating: 13/14 = 93%

  • Price: $129.00
  • Positions: (4)Front facing in, front facing out, hip, or back
  • Min & Max: 8 – 40 pounds
  • Description: The Pikkolo may not have as many reviews as the ERGO, but those that purchase it really seem to love it. It has one of the highest customer satisfaction ratings. What makes this soft structured baby carrier so special? First of all, it offers all 4 carrying positions, including the front facing-out position, which is pretty rare. It also offers an internal X support system designed to offer more lumbar support, which is perfect for carrying heavier babies.  The shoulder straps are wide and padded with memory foam, the same stuff you would find in a Tempurpedic mattress. Also, you can carry your little one from 8 pounds all the way up to 40 pounds without the need to purchase an infant insert. The Pikkolo offers a cinching mechanism which basically narrows or widens the seat depending on the size of your baby. For more information, check out the Pikkolo Soft Structured Baby Carrier Review.

 

Babybjorn Miracle Carrier

Babybjorn Miracle - Front Facing-in

Babybjorn Miracle @ Amazon for $127.56


Customer Rating: 52/60 = 87%

  • Price: $184.95
  • Positions: (2)Front facing-in or front facing-out
  • Min & Max: 8 – 26 pounds
  • Description: The Babybjorn Miracle Baby Carrier allows you to carry your baby right from day one until approximately 15 months, without the need for additional infant inserts or pillows. This soft structured baby carrier comes with plenty of adjustments including adjustable head support, adjustable back support, and a generously padded adjustable waist belt. The Babybjorn Miracles unique two-piece design allows for undisturbed transfer of your baby to his/her crib. The reason I consider the Babybjorn Miracle to be one of the best baby carriers on the market, is because it’s extremely easy to use, and it offers more adjustments for the wearer. You can choose where you want your baby to be, whether you want him/her high up on your chest within kissing range, or lower on your stomach. You also choose where you want the majority of the weight to be distributed. You HAVE to see the video demonstration to truly understand how magnificent this soft structured baby carrier really is. Check out the Babybjorn Miracle Review here.

 

Scootababy Carrier

Scootababy Hip Carrier - Black

Scootababy @ Amazon $119.00


Customer Rating: 35/41 = 85%

  • Price: $119.00
  • Positions: (3) Hip carry, front, and back
  • Min & Max: 12 – 37 pounds
  • Description: The Scootababy is a unique soft structured baby carrier. It is designed specifically for the natural hip carrying position. It’s made with 100% cotton chino twill and offers a quilted microfiber lining. When I first noticed the Scootababy, I was a bit skeptical. I kind of figured that the one shoulder strap design would make you feel awkward, or uneven. It turns out that it’s actually quite comfortable. Carrying your baby on your hip is just one of those things that comes natural, we all do it, with or without a baby carrier. That’s why I like the Scootababy so much. It’s also extremely easy to load and unload. It does offer both front and back carry as well, however, I would not recommend it if that’s what you’re looking for. I would only recommend it if you’re looking for a good hip carrier. You’ll have to check out the video demonstration in my review to really get a sense of how easy and natural it is. For more information, check out the Scootababy Review.

 

Beco Butterfly II Baby Carrier

Beco Butterfly II - Front Facing-in -Niko

Beco Butterfly II @ Amazon for $119.50


Customer Rating: 102/120 = 85%

  • Price: $145.00
  • Positions: (2)Front facing in, or back
  • Min & Max: 6 – 45 pounds
  • Description: The Beco Butterfly II is THE soft structured baby carrier I recommend to beginners. The reason being is that it offers a unique internal sling that makes transitioning from front carry to back carry extremely simple and safe. On top of that, this soft structured baby carrier also comes with a removable infant insert that allows you to carry your newborn. The design itself is sleek and stylish, and it comes in a variety of different colors and prints. Also, the body of the carrier is taller and wider than some, which means more support for your growing baby. The only real drawback is that because of the internal sling, which is basically a separate piece of material between you and your baby, breastfeeding while carrying is difficult. If you would like more information, check out the Beco Butterfly II Review.

 

BABYBJÖRN Synergy

Babybjorn Baby Carrier Synergy - Black - Forward Facing-out

Babybjorn Synergy @ Amazon $113.32

4star
Customer Rating: 119/146 = 81%

  • Price: $179.95
  • Positions: (2)Front only, with facing in and facing out.
  • Min & Max: 8 – 26 pounds
  • Description: The Synergy is the most popular Babybjorn Carrier, with the highest customer satisfaction rating. It’s made from smooth, 3D mesh material, which makes it extremely breathable and cool. It also offers a tad bit more lumbar support than the original, and the straps are a bit wider as well. In general, the Babybjorn’s are known for being some of the best soft structured baby carriers for newborns. They offer a unique two piece design that allows you to transfer your baby from carrier to crib virtually undisturbed. On top of that, the Synergy is extremely lightweight, and easy to use. For more information, including where to find the best price, check out the Babybjorn Synergy Review.

 

BabyHawk Oh Snap Baby Carrier

BabyHawk On Snap Baby Carrier - Back Carry with toddler

BabyHawk On Snap @ Amazon $101.40

4star
Customer Rating: 13/16 = 81%

  • Price: $149.00
  • Positions: (2)Front facing in, and back carry
  • Min & Max: 15 – 45 pounds
  • Description: The BabyHawk Oh Snap is basically a Mei Tai Carrier with buckles that clip instead of straps that tie. It is considered to be one of the best soft structured baby carriers for a toddler, mainly because it offers a wider and taller seat with seat darts, which basically provide a sturdier, more supported position for your child. In addition, this toddler carrier offers triple padded shoulder straps that can be crossed in the back while using the front carry position, giving the wearer more support. The waist belt is also one of the widest I’ve seen. Plus, this soft structured baby carrier offers a ton of adjustments.  It is designed to fit women’s sizes from 0 to 22, and men’s sizes S to XXL. For more information, check out the BabyHawk Oh Snap Review.

 

BABYBJÖRN Organic Comfort Carrier

Babybjorn Comfort Baby Carrier - Black

Babybjorn Comfort @ Amazon $134.15

4star
Customer Rating: 67/83 = 81%

  • Price: $179.95
  • Positions: (2)Front only, with facing in and facing out.
  • Min & Max: 13 – 31 pounds (front facing out 13 to 26 pounds & front facing in 13 to 31 pounds)
  • Description: When it comes to comfortable front baby carriers, the Bjorn Comfort is by far one of the best. Offering fully padded adjustable shoulder straps and an adjustable waist belt, Baby’s weight is transferred to your hips and what is left is spread evenly across your back and shoulders. The Babybjorn Comfort is the only Babybjorn Carrier that goes up to 31 pounds. It offers adjustable head support for your little one, as well as an added leg position that enables you to carry larger babies front facing in comfortably. For more information on this soft structured baby carrier, check out the Babybjorn Comfort Review.

 

BABYBJÖRN Active Carrier

Babybjorn Baby Carrier Active - Black

Babybjorn Active @ Amazon for $77.24

4star
Customer Rating: 183/232 = 79%

  • Price: $129.95
  • Positions:(2)Front only, with facing in and facing out.
  • Min & Max: 8 – 26 pounds
  • Description: The Babybjorn Active Baby Carrier offers everything that the original offers, with the addition of enhanced  lumbar support and lighter fabric. The Babybjorn Carriers are the best baby carriers for newborns, and are designed with breastfeeding in mind. They offer plenty of privacy, therefore allowing you to breastfeed comfortably while wearing. For more information, check out the Babybjorn Active Review.

 

ERGO Performance Baby Carrier

Ergo Baby Performance - Grey

Ergo Performance @ Amazon for $139.00

4star
Customer Rating: 117/144 = 81%

  • Price: $135.00
  • Positions: (3)Front facing in, hip, or back
  • Min & Max: 15 – 45 pounds (will support a newborn with an infant insert sold separately for $25)
  • Description: Out of all the ERGO Baby Carriers, the ERGO Performance is specifically designed to keep the wearer and Baby cool and comfortable. With a breathable mesh interior, and a shell made from durable, water repellent fabric, the ERGO Performance is one of the best soft structured baby carriers for outdoor activities. Also included, contoured, padded shoulder straps and waist belt, lined with cotton wicking to keep you dry. Plus, the ERGO Performance is fully adjustable, made to fit anyone from 5″ to 6.5″ tall. The shoulder straps adjust from 24″ to 45″, and the waist belt adjusts from 30″ to 55″. For more information, check out the ERGO Performance Review.

 

ERGO Sport Baby Carrier

ERGO Sport Baby Carrier - Black -Front Carry

ERGO Sport @ Amazon for $115.00

4star
Customer Rating: 58/77 = 75%

  • Price: $115.00
  • Positions: (3)Front facing in, hip, or back
  • Min & Max: 15 – 45 pounds (will support a newborn with an infant insert sold separately for $25)
  • Description: The ERGO Sport Baby Carrier offers everything that the Original ERGO offers, including all the positions and the maximum weight capacity. The only difference is that it offers breathable material, and more adjust-ability. The shoulder straps adjust from 27″ to 49″, 4 inches more then the original. This soft structured baby carrier also offers a detachable sleeping hood which is perfect for nap-time or privacy. For more information, check out the ERGO Sport Review. To learn more about the differences between the Original, Sport, and Performance, click here.

 

Lillebaby 5 Position EveryWear Carrier

Lillebaby Everywear Baby Carrier - Hip carry

Lillebaby @ Amazon for $115.00

3star
Customer Rating: 31/46 = 67%

  • Price: $99.95
  • Positions: (5) Front facing in, out, cradle, hip, and back.
  • Min & Max: 7 – 42 pounds
  • Description: The Lillebaby Everywear comes in the original lightweight version, or the sport version, which offers additional breath-ability. Both offer max adjust-ability for Mom/Dad, as well as an adjustable seat for the correct ergonomic carrying position at every age. What makes the Lillebaby Carrier one of the best is the fact that it offers the MOST carrying positions. It is truly meant to be your all-in-one soft structured baby carrier, offering every function, at every stage, from birth up to 5 years of age. For more information, check out the Lillebaby Everywear Review.

 

Related Articles:

Soft Structured Baby Carrier Features 101 - The more you know about what features are available, the more satisfied you’ll be with your purchase. Let me give you an idea of what the best baby carriers have to offer.

The BEST Baby Carrier – What To Look For – When it comes to choosing the best baby carriers for you and your little one, there are a few things to keep in mind. For instance, weight capacity and carrying positions….

Baby Carrier Video Demonstrations – Intended to show you your options, and give you an idea of how each baby carrier works. Also included are full in-depth baby carrier reviews

Back to Top

Did you like this? Share it:
Soft Structured Baby Carrier Comparison Reviews , , , , , ,

2 comments


  1. Flora

    I just want to say, GREAT post! Very informative. Looks like you really know you Baby Carriers.

  2. Pingback: Car Seat Recommendations - What Car Seat Do I Buy?

Leave a Reply