These two backpack child carriers have several similarities, however, there are a few unique features that set them apart.
Both the Deuter Kid Comfort II and the FC 3.0 Kelty Child Carrier offer lightweight aluminum frames, and 5-point adjustable child safety harness’s with adjustable seats. Both backpack child carriers also offer padded shoulder straps, and padded waist belts with storage, as well as adjustable sternum straps, and ventilated back panels. Both the Deuter Kid Comfort II and the Kelty Child Carrier also offer kickstands and load lifter straps for easy loading and unloading, as well as large storage compartments, and a max load weight of roughly 50 pounds.
The Kelty Child Carrier offers an auto-deploy kickstand for easy loading and unloading. It deploys when the shoulder straps are loosened and collapses when they are placed back on the shoulders. The Deuter Kid Comfort II offers a locking kickstand for added safety.
The Kelty Child Carrier also offers a weather protect sun/rain hood, whereas the Deuter Kid Comfort II’s sun/rain shield is sold separately.
The Kelty Child Carrier also offers a zip-off diaper bag, and changing pad, whereas the Deuter Kid Comfort II offers a zippered water belly hydration pocket, and mesh water bottle pockets.
While both backpack child carriers offer a ventilated back panel, the Deuter Kid Comfort II offers 3D air-mesh lining for more breath-ability.
The torso adjustments are slightly different as well. The Kelty Child Carrier offers a sliding torso adjuster activated by a pin. The Deuter Kid Comfort II offers a velcro quick-fit sliding torso-adjuster. Both are quite simple to operate, however the Kelty Child Carrier is a tad bit quicker but it’s also been known to slip on occasion.
The Deuter Kid Comfort II offers side-entry, which makes loading and unloading your little one extremely easy. They can basically load themselves. With the Kelty Child Carrier you have to lift your little one above the seat and feed his/her legs through the wholes.
Lastly, the Deuter Kid Comfort II also offer a Vari-Flex waist belt that pivots and moves with your body. So instead of trudging up the hill with a stiff pack attached to your back, this one moves with you. This is by far the best advantage to the Deuter Kid Comfort Carriers.
As far as reviews go, the Kelty FC 3.0 is by far the most popular. With 63 out of 76 reviewers rating it 4 to 5 stars, with 5 being the max. That’s 83% customer satisfaction.
The Deuter Kid Comfort II is not as well known as Kelty and therefore has less reviews. It did have 36 out of 39 reviewers on Amazon rate it 4 to 5 stars. I also looked at 3 different backpacking websites, such as REI, Back County Edge, and Trail Space. I found a total of 14 reviews, all of which rated the Deuter Kid Comfort II 5 stars, that’s 100% customer satisfaction. Also, I personally own the Deuter Kid Comfort II Child Carrier, and I’m 100% satisfied, if that counts for anything.
FC 3.0 Kelty Child Carrier
If you’re looking for a very basic set-up that also includes a rain/sun shade, then the FC 3.0 Kelty Child Carrier may be perfect. It doesn’t offer all the bells and whistles that the Deuter Kid Comfort II offers but it does come with a zip-off diaper bag and changing pad. Plus you also get the auto-deploy kickstand which is a really neat feature. You can get the Kelty FC 3.0 at Amazon for $249.99.
FYI: There is a newer version of this backpack child carrier called the Kelty Pathfinder 3.0. It comes with all of the same features except it now includes hydration pack storage, and an easier child safety harness, and an easy access water bottle pocket on the waist belt. You can get the Kelty Pathfinder 3.0 at Amazon for $279.95.
Deuter Kid Comfort II Child Carrier
If you’re looking for a backpack child carrier with plenty of storage, one that’s easy to load and unload, and extremely comfortable, the Deuter Kid Comfort II is perfect! You can get the Deuter Kid Comfort II at Amazon for $238.00.
If you’re still undecided, take a look at the full reviews listed below, including pro’s and con’s, as well as video demonstrations.
Best Baby Backpack Carriers, AKA Child Carriers – This list includes the best baby backpack carriers on the market. Compare prices, features, and customer feedback. Find the BEST baby backpack carrier for you and your family.
Best Rated Child Carriers – These two child carriers/baby backpack carriers are at the top of the list when it comes to performance and ratings.