These two soft structured baby carriers have a few things in common. For instance, both the Scootababy and the ERGO Baby offer an ergonomically correct sitting position verses a hanging crotch position. Both are also extremely handy to use and are made with 100% cotton. Both the ERGO and the Scootababy offer a wide padded waist belt for comfort and proper weight distribution, and both are also rated to carry up to around 37 pounds, with a minimum weight of around 12 or 15 pounds. The ERGO Baby Carrier does offer an infant insert, sold separately, that makes it possible to carry infants from 7 to 15 pounds. Both are also priced about the same, with the Scootababy Carrier listing for about $119.00, and the ERGO Baby Carrier listing for $115.00.So, what’s the difference?
The main difference between these two baby carriers is in design. The ERGO Baby Carrier has two foam padded shoulder straps, whereas the Scootababy only offer one shoulder strap. The reason for this is that the Scootababy Carrier is designed specifically for the natural hip carrying position. The ERGO Baby Carrier is more of a multi-position baby carrier that also offers the hip carry position. The Scootababy Carrier offers a polartec fleece shoulder strap that cups the shoulder, distributing the weight evenly for a comfortable fit. Now, the Scootababy also offers both front and back carrying positions, but it really is best used as a hip carrier only.
Both baby carriers have received excellent reviews. The ERGO Baby Carrier, which has been around for a lot longer and is one of the most popular baby carriers on the market, had 323 out of 372 reviewers rate it 4 to 5 stars, with 5 being the max. That’s an 87% customer satisfaction rating! The Scootababy had 32 out of 38 reviewers rate it 4 to 5 stars, and even though it had less reviews, the quality of the reviews was outstanding. It ended up with an 84% customer satisfaction rating. Just so you know, anything above 80% is excellent!
Scootababy Baby Carrier
If you are looking for a baby carrier to use specifically for the hip carry position, I would definitely recommend the Scootababy. It’s extremely easy to use, comfortable and natural, and lightweight. It also comes with it’s own nylon drawstring carrying bag. The Scootababy Baby Carrier is currently on SALE at Amazon for $105.00.
ERGO Baby Carrier Original
If you’re looking for an extremely comfortable baby carrier with multiple carrying positions including the hip carry, I would definitely recommend the ERGO Baby Carrier. It’s cozy, comfy, and warm. You can also purchase an infant insert to go along with it which will allow you to carry your little one from day one. The ERGO Baby Carrier is currently on SALE at Target for $115.00.
If you’re still undecided, check out the full reviews listed below, including the good and the bad, customer feedback, and video demonstrations.
Best Hip Carriers – The below list of baby carriers all offer the natural hip carry position. Some offer multiple positions including front and back carry as well. These are the best hip carriers on the market.
Best Multi-Position/Back Baby Carriers – Back Baby Carriers can make a world of difference in your busy lifestyle. Below I’ve listed some of the best back baby carriers on the market.